Despite a strong start for Guillermo del Toro’s Crimson Peak at the beginning of the weekend, the R-rated gothic horror romance ultimately fell short of expectations, earning just $12.85 million and settling for fourth place. The good news is that it also made $13 million overseas, but that is still well short of the film’s $55 million budget and there is some strong horror competition coming up next weekend. The family horror flick Goosebumps ultimately won out with $23.5 million, which was probably to be expected, although that was a little weaker than expected as well. Meanwhile The Martian fell to second place while Steven Spielberg’s Bridge of Spies opened in third with $15.38 million. Sony’s other family-friendly October offering Hotel Transylvania 2 rounded out the top 5.

1. Goosebumps — $23.5M
2. The Martian — $21.5M
3. Bridge of Spies — $15.38M
4. Crimson Peak — $12.85M
5. Hotel Transylvania 2 — $12.25M
6. Pan — $5.86M
7. The Intern — $5.41M
8. Sicario — $4.50M
9. Woodlawn — $4.10M
10. Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials — $2.75M