Viscerally Speaking: 10 Modern Action Scenes That Shook My Reality

Children of Men
With Wanted ripping up the box office and polarizing action fans, I decided to take a look at some recent action sequences that have really had me on the edge of my seat. Personally, I wasn’t very impressed by Timur Bekmambetov’s over-the-top approach, but I may be in the minority. His use of bullet time, slow motion, fast motion, p.o.v. and CG has inspired some while inciting some major eye rolling from others. Personally, it’s not the CG that bothers me, but rather the stale approach. Just have a look at the following list for examples of complex, CG-heavy set pieces with some serious weight behind them. Better yet, we’ll also look at the simple approach in creating the ultimate visceral action experience.

Before we begin, there’s one major stipulation to this list: I’m only looking at films from the year 2000 on. I’ve also decided against including films that I have not yet seen or have not yet been made. I’ll be saving those for my ’10 Films Which Haven’t Been Made Yet That, Based on Leaked Set Photos and Concept Art, May Include Action Sequences That Will Shake My Reality’ list. It’s interesting to note that of the ten choices, there are only 7 directors. That’s right, three directors have two films on this list. Eat that! I’m sure there’s a shitload of notable films I’ll be leaving off of here, so feel free to share some examples or contend my choices in the comments section.

10. Spider-Man 2 – Train Sequence

Spider-Man 2

Spider-Man 2 is probably my favourite super-hero film of all time. I find it utterly rewatchable. This is mainly due to it’s precise tonal balancing act, teetering back and forth between a perfect mix of fantasy and drama. I think it’s safe to say I’m not alone on this one. I was excited to see the re-teaming of Raimi and cinematographer Bill Pope (Army of Darkness, Darkman), and thrilled that the re-union seemed to have put Sam in a nostalgic state of mind. I know some Spider-Man purists may have found Raimi’s Doc Ock ‘hospital sequence’ a little too self-refrential, but I thought it was a great return to form and a reminder of how much I’ve missed the old Sam. Having said that, as much as I loved that scene, it’s NOT the number 10 on this list. As far as CG heavy action sequences go, I’d have to say Spider-Man 2’s subway sequence is the best of the entire trilogy.

I love the use of space around the fast-moving elevated cars as a platform for Raimi to exploit the powers of Spidey and Doc Ock. It’s almost dizzying watching the two battle it out standing upright on the side of the car, flipping the axis of the scene and thus adding an whole new dimension. I especially love Doc Ock slamming Spider-Man through the car windows.

The problem when you get two somewhat balanced super-power’s fighting it out is the lack of a threat. Things can get boring pretty quickly. Thankfully, a subway car full of innocent bystander’s provides some good collateral damage. Spidey spends most of his time catching flying bodies in giant make-shift web-based safety nets, all the while holding Doc Ock at bay. Pretty intense. Not to mention his final self-sacrificial human-train-brake stunt. All in all a good time and a creative use of CG.

9. King Kong – Dino-Chase

King Kong

Although I wasn’t a HUGE fan of Peter Jackson’s King Kong, I must admit his Spielberg-ian ‘dino-chase’ set piece was pretty intense. (If this was a top 20, Jurassic Park: Lost World would’ve made my list.) I just love how ridiculously out of control things get when the Bronto’s clumsily stumble over eachother. Sure the compositing may have been a little sketchy, but the image itself was pretty stunning.

Then we’re stuck in a narrow cavernous pit as T-Rex’s hang from vines, just out of reach of Ann Darrow. This scene had me smiling simply due to the ‘damned if you do, damned if you don’t’ nature of it all. The second things seem to be looking up, the situation just gets worse and worse. I specifically remember the audience in the theatre responding strongly to Jackson’s disgusting, giant insects. Definitely one of the creepier uses of computer generated creatures.

8. United 93 – Storming the Cockpit

United 93

I suppose it’s debatable whether or not this sequence belongs on an ‘action’ list (possibly even a bit disrespectful?), but there’s no deying that the final 15 minutes of Paul Greengrass’ ‘United 93′ (My number 1 film of 2006) was one of this decades most intense, visceral, and overall stressful moments in cinema. An impressive feat considering we all know how it was going to end.

People are pretty down on the ‘shakey cam’ action, but I think it’s a tool that, when used appropriately, can be quite powerful. This particular scene benefitted greatly from the verite approach. The sloppiness of this scene is one of the more positively frustrating things I’ve seen on film. Watching this group of people attempt to breach the cockpit as the entire plane is banked left and right is almost unbearable. I still can’t believe the level of immersion Greengrass achieved with this scene. One notable element is the music, which relies on a slow aching build rather than a typically percussion-heavy approach. How people can write this film off as ‘boring’ blows my mind.

7. Oldboy – Hallway Fight

Old Boy

Speaking of sloppy fights, I was especially surprised to see such an ungracious action sequence in an Asian film. (Is that racist?) I think the hallway fight scene in Oldboy was the most memorable moment for me. (Even beating out the live Octupus!) I love the complete aversion to cutting and shakiness, instead relying on a simple dolly movement to allow you to completely analyze the action. Also, the side-scrolling video game imagery is pretty cool. I just love the desperation of the scene.

6. Eastern Promises – Naked Knife Fight

Eastern Promises

The approach is simple and effective. A knife fight in a bath house. The catch? A naked Viggo Mortensen. The power of this scene is in its simplicity, relying on pure hand to hand combat with a twist. Putting the ‘hero’ in such a vulnerable setting triples the threat and helps the audience sense every swing of the knife blade, wincing twice has hard every time the blade makes contact. Not only is it physically intimidating, but the idea of 1. wrestling with a naked man covered in blood, and 2. defending yourself form a knife wielding Russian in the nude, are equally unimaginable and disgusting. It works from both points of view. To top it off, Cronenberg manages to find some wonderfully brutal ways to put an end to the whole sha-bang. A great scene.

5. Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring – Troll Fight

Lord of the Rings

Although Jackson’s giant battle sequences didn’t do much for me, I do remember really reacting to the Troll Fight in the first film. In fact, it may be the only part of the trilogy I really remember. I think what made this scene work for me was the choice to drop the score. The sound design sells the entire scene. Looking back on it now the CG effects do feel a touch dated, but the man-in-suit Goblins are still pretty creepy. I don’t think the remaining films of the trilogy ever captured such a viscerally compelling action sequence. I love the shaft of light in the middle of the room.

4. Bourne Ultimatum

Bourne Ultimatum

Rather than focusing on actual sequences, I’d like to point out two specific moments in The Bourne Ultimatum that sent shivers up my spine. The first; Matt Damon jumping from one building through the window of an opposite building. A pretty standard move that is made thrilling by the camera weilding stuntman that follows right behind him! What a great shot. This is what I mean when I talk about wanting to feel as though the camera man is right there, face first in the shit. The fact that they did it practically makes it all the more awesome.

Second is the ‘desperate measures’ taken by Bourne whenever he’s in a pinch. This guy will do whatever it takes, no matter how bruised and battered the resulting actions will leave him. In this case, he drives full speed in reverse off the top of a parking garage. I love the fact that it’s not pretty, and definitely not graceful. He does what he has to do and doesn’t give a fuck if it looks like ballet. GO BOURNE!

3. Kill Bill – Crazy 88’s

Kill Bill

The next two choices are both Tarantino films. Odd, considering that in the 90’s, he was simply known as the guy who can write great dialogue.

The body count goes through the roof as Uma Thurman cuts her way through the Crazy 88’s in a carefully choreographed sequence that reminds me how it can be to watch carefully choreographed action unfold under controlled, cinematic conditions. Robert Richardson’s trademark spot-lit overhead key lights add a fantastic glow to everything, and Tarantino’s knack for combining music with imagery (in this case, the 5,6,7,8’s) really shines through here. I’m excited to see the uncut version, sans black & white. I have a strange love/hate relationship with kung fu. I’m not a fan of wire work, but it seems the sloppier it is, the more I dig it. In this case, Tarantino seemed to be challenging the Shaw Brothers kung fu films of the 1970’s. There’s no concern for realism. In fact, the opposite holds true. This fight is meant to be pure cinema. Blood spraying as a representation of death rather then a realistic portrayal of it.

2. Death Proof – Car Chase

Death Proof

Although I loved the entire film, even hater’s have to admit the two major action set pieces in Tarantino’s Death Proof are amazing. The final 30 minutes of the film are essentially built as a tribute to stunt drivers and the road films of the 70’s, showcasing Zoe Bell as a new female talent in the industry. Tarantino manages to capture every possible cool angle throughout this chase, and does proudly without any CG. (Maybe some wire removal?) Everything is shot low to the ground as the road blurs by, tipping you off as to how fast they really are going. It’s a lengthy sequence that ends with a surprising twist, and a definite return to form for Kurt Russel. If only Neil Marshall’s ‘Doomsday’ took this similar approach to it’s car sequences.

1. Children of Men – The Long Take

Children of Men

Here is the perfect example of how to use CG in an action scene; invisibly.

As with the previously mentioned hallway scene in Oldboy, Alfonso Cuaron seems to be inspired by the first person immersion of video games like Call of Duty and Medal of Honour, choosing to play out his two major action sequences in long, single takes. (with hidden cuts of course) The goal, of course, is to simulate the look and feel of war journalism. Mission accomplished. The final scene of the film plays out like a Universal Studios ride. (minus the creepy mechanical E.T. saying your name as you exit) Blood splatters onto the lens, explosions shoot dust and debris everywhere, characters cross paths only to lose each other and eventually meet up again in different locations. Watching Clive Owen traverse the battle field is probably the closest I’ll get to experiencing the thrill of paint ball. Or war I suppose. Nah, paintball.



  • Awesome post! The recent debate over Wanted also inspired me to look back over recent action films and ask which scenes impressed me and why.

    I didn’t write down a list or anything but I actually came up with a similar collection of scenes. The train scene in SM2 (also the chase scene that ends with Peter Parker pulling up in the stolen car), T-Rex in King Kong, Kill Bill (my favorite fight scene is the one with Daryl Hannah), every chase scene in Children of Men. If it had been a numbered list Death Proof would probably been number one, one of the coolest bits of cinema I’ve ever scene in the theater.

    I excluded things like No Country or Assassination of J James which are more about building suspense. I love the minimalism and the clumsiness of the shoot out in Jesse James but it just doesnt feel like a great ACTION scene.

    Grizzly fight is Grizzly Man is stunning. There’s a cool japanese film I caught called Pistol Opera that has some fun / absurd shoot outs. I really love some of the shoot outs in Miami Vice, partly for the way they feel slightly off.

    I didn’t think of Old Boy or United 93 (very clever pick) but I should have.

    That awesome tracking shot in Ong Bak came to mind. Also, I personally love the Pirates films and I think they contain some great set pieces and visual ideas. And I also thought of Ang Lee’s Hulk. The part where he fights the military in the desert is great.

    I like that you did not include any Ridley Scott.

    I’m surprised you didn’t include any Spielberg. Minority Report has some great chase scenes and it was one of the first films I thought of. Actually it would probably be number two on my (hypothetical) list.
    What sets Spielberg’s action set pieces apart for me is the way he mixes action with humor. I love the way his action ideas turn into comedic ideas in a way that feels completely
    natural.

    On a related note; I forget where I saw the interview but I was watching something where Spielberg was praising Mike Bay for his use of humor, and I just about lost it. Bay’s films are like a how-to manual of how not to combine action and comedy. Spielberg and Raimi find the humor in their scene, Bay just cuts away to footage of a fat black guy dancing or a farting robot or something.

    Just for the record, I think Bad Boys II has a good car chase.

    @ “I’ve also decided against including films that I have not yet seen or have not yet been made.”

    funny stuff.

  • Ryan

    I felt compelled to comment on this list piece by piece so here it goes:

    10. “Spider-Man 2 is probably my favourite super-hero film of all time.”

    Ohmuhgod yes! I already said this in a top five list on a previous comments section on this very site. I agree with almost every word of what you said although I definitely would have placed it much higher on the list. If only they took Sandman out of the third one : (

    9. The movie suffered from the same thing Spider-Man 3 did: an over bloated script. But despite that I thought the dino-chase was incredible (albeit poorly composited).

    8. I haven’t seen United 93 but it has made its way into my queue.

    7.”Is that racist?” No, it’s true. Great choice.

    6. I would have went with the diner scene (for the seamless CG) in the previous Cronenburg/Mortensen effort but this scene definitely had balls. Easy pun was obviously intended.

    5. I’d go with the Battle of Helm’s Deep here but the scene you chose is good enough. The CG felt dated on day one but it didn’t bother me because the framing and sound design was generally great. Am I getting that you didn’t love the LOTR trilogy?

    4. Haven’t seen this one all the way through yet. There’s another for my queue.

    “This is what I mean when I talk about wanting to feel as though the camera man is right there, face first in the shit.”

    Ahhh…ok. On the last episode you made it seem like you didn’t just want the feeling but also the reality of that.

    “The fact that they did it practically makes it all the more awesome.”

    I can’t deny it; I still go into happy seizures during the fire scene in The Prodigal Son because of the fact that it both looked and was physically real.

    3. Watch 80’s Golden Harvest films directed by Samo Hung starting with the aforementioned one and hopefully you’ll change your tune. The 70’s Shaw Brothers will always be a distant second to 80’s Golden Harvest in my seasoned kung fu opinion. Btw, I hate wire fu as well. It got way played out before most people got a taste with Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon.

    2. I’m not going to get into it as I am running out of virtual breath, but I didn’t like Death Proof and the reasons are various and significant. I’ve loved everything else Tarantino has done so I’m not a hater. I’ll just say that this is the only time Rodriquez bested Tarantino at his own game. The scene was great though.

    1. This is the only scene on the list that I would have put in the same slot. I used to play paintball all the time up until two years ago and yes lol the scene does feel like a good game. The only thing is I could never convince anyone (myself included) to follow through with my extremely illegal fantasy of playing “Urban Paintball” in a derelict section of downtown.

    I change my mind Jay…you don’t blindly hate CG. I just think you got wound up in that Wanted review.

  • Great list, Jay. I’d have included the Elle Driver vs. Beatrix Kiddo fight from Kill Bill Vol. 2 in there somewhere (probably instead of either the LotR or United 93 scenes), but otherwise pretty much agree with what you’ve got to say here.

    It’s an odd coincidence that my co-host and I over at The Sidetracked Podcast (http://sidetrackedpodcast.blogspot.com/ for anyone who may be interested) ran down our lists of our favorite movie fight scenes of all time just one week ago on the show. We focused on fights rather than the broader range of any “action scenes” and I didn’t stick to only films from the current decade, but here is my list just the same for the hell of it:

    10.) Raiders of the Lost Ark – Indiana Jones vs. Pat Roach on the tarmac
    9.) Kung Fu Hustle – Sing vs. the two harpists
    8.) Spiderman 2 – Spiderman vs. Doctor Octopus on the elevated train
    7.) Aliens – Ripley in the Power Loader vs. the queen alien aboard the Sulaco
    6.) Who Am I? – The rooftop fight
    5.) Kill Bill Vol. 2 – Elle Driver vs. Beatrix Kiddo in Budd’s trailer
    4.) From Russia With Love – James Bond vs. Red Grant on the Orient Express
    3.) The Way of the Gun – The courtyard shootout
    2.) Police Story – The mall fight
    1.) The Matrix – The lobby shootout

  • Liney

    How bizarre! These lists are always subjective, but half the ones you’ve listed are ones I always bring up when mentioning good action sequences, and the other half, although i wouldn’t have thought of them, I agree with.

    Maybe I would have put something older in there too – the car sequence from Raiders or something – but great list. I remain convinced though that more films could have great action sequences if they didn’t lose sight of what makes an action sequence visceral. Most seem to mistake being ridiculously impossible with being affective.

  • Liney

    …oh, I remember getting a visceral thrill from one of the early aviation sequences in teh Aviator. However put together the new Star Wars films (which didn’t have a single decent dogfight in them) should be made to watch and analyse that.

    As sh*t as the new Star Wars trilogy is, the Darth Maul lightsaber battle is pretty awesome, although you could argue that it’s more aesthetically pleasing than visceral.

  • Couldn’t agree more with the Children of Men. If anyone hasn’t seen that movie yet, get in on it. The whole movie is great, but “the long scene” is an unmistakable movie masterpiece.

    The others I agreed with you on: Kill Bill – the Crazy 88s fight scene, Borne Ultimatum, and the wicked shower fight scene in Eastern Promises that made me squirm. You can’t help but feel it!

  • nice photoshoped.

  • Ryan M.

    The problem of two Ryans with a “y” is acknowledged and solved. I am now Ryan M. and I was poster #2 up there and am all over the place on the last few posts. I had to geek and clarify.

  • swarez

    One CGI filled scene that really messed me up was the opening scene in Irreversible.
    Actually the rape scene is also CGI enhanced, guess which part.

  • Great list Jay!

    For practical stunts

    I loved the staircase fight in Tom Yum Goong (The Protector) as well as the massive Bar fight in Ong Bak.

    But the scene that does really sing is the ‘capture the flag opening on ONG BAK.

    There is a crazy parallel truck action sequence in BORN TO FIGHT which has a guy fall off (and bounce) between the two moving trucks which is simply off the hook in how dangerous it looks.

    Can’t forget the first time seeing The opening chapter of Saving Private Ryan.

    And the lobby sequence in the Matrix is pretty darn spectacular.

    Furthermore, the gun-kata stuff in Equilibrium (particular a sequence punctuated and accentuated with gun muzzle flashes was awesome in a ‘I can’t believe nobody has done this before’)

    Banlieue 13 has that parkour magic of speed and immediacy of great practical stunts.

    Ronin has a couple of pretty wicked car chases too.

    Lastly, I want to point out the opening chase sequence in NARC which is an absolute winner in terms of intensity and quality use of handheld camera.

  • On the Michael Mann front. Miami Vice and Collateral ratchet up the visceral and confusion to satisfying results, but the big street shoot out in HEAT is an absolute marvel.

  • Matt

    What? Where’s “Nuking the Fridge”? What a shitty list. jk.

  • @Rusty James: Minority Report was definitely on my mind while writing that list. (As was JP: Lost World, which I know a lot of people didn’t like) I love Spielberg’s sense of geography during his action pieces, and would’ve definitely included it in a top 20. I have to revisit that film (Minority Report) soon so I can refresh my memory. I really enjoyed the car hopping and the whole jet pack sequence.

    @Ryan: I liked the LOTR trilogy, but not as much as some I suspect. The first one stands out most clearly in my memory, and I felt a lot of the action in the other two films was a little bloated.

    @Liney: The only reason I didn’t put any older films in the list is because I was trying to stick with movies made this decade. Maybe in the future I’ll put together an overall list.

    @kurt: I knew I’d forget some good ones. Specifically, I agree with your mention of Mann’s Miami Vice. I loved the Cops-esque shoot out at the end. As for the Asian cinema you mentioned, I have not seen a single one of them. I’m pretty picky when it comes to that stuff, but I’ll have to check out Ong Bak in the near future.

  • Nice to see a post from Jay– slow day at work? Just kidding. Good stuff. Agreed with most every one of the choices.

  • joe

    Nice. The United 93 and Death Proof ones were big for me. Both were really intense, for different reasons.

  • Primal

    Awesome list Jay. I agree with most of your choices man.

    I’d also agree with Kurt by saying I loved the staircase fight from The Protector and would put it in my top 3. If you haven’t watched it yet, then you better get on it!

  • Greg

    Hmmm…Ong Bak has so many great action sequences. The staircase scene in the Protector is friggin’ badass. Good call.

    Am I the only one that thought the Pod race in the Phantom Menace was cool?

  • Mike

    Great list. I would have the main chase scene in Ronin on my list.

  • I absolutely love this post…but hey, who’s the other Mike??

  • Ian

    Pretty apt list. You’re next one should be action sequences from movies up until 2000. I’ll let you make it a top 25 or so if you need it.

  • Swarez is on to something. Next should be favorite cgi enhanced rape scenes.

  • pissedoff

    The Car Chase scene in Death Proof wasn’t nearly fast enough, making me wonder why the chick didn’t just hop off the hood on too many occasions.
    That Spiderman 2 scene was rad, but I can’t agree about it being the best super hero movie (especially after Iron Man came out).
    The rest of your list is great. You are great.

  • Hussein

    cant believe you didn’t put the scene from saving private ryan or gladiator

  • Jordan

    The greatest action sequence in the history of film is the climactic chase in *The Road Warrior*.

    Everything that happens in that scene is real. They literally strapped a bunch of stunt-men to rocket-cars and sent them careening through the desert. Legendary.

    Also, not mentioning anything from *Aliens* (Powerloader Fight?) or *The Matrix* (Lobby Sequence?) is a pretty serious oversight.

  • Hey Jordan,

    If you read the opening of the article, you would notice that I’m ranking films of this decade, from 2000 on.

    Thanks

  • @Hussein: Saving Private Ryan would’ve made a top 20, but I wasn’t a big fan of Gladiator.

    @Jordan: P.S. I agree with your assessment of The Road Warrior. Again, it would’ve definitely made my list if I was looking at films pre-2000.

  • Swarez

    One of the best CGI enhanced action films ever, pre 2000…Starship Troopers. The swarming of the fortress is just awesome.

  • Great list but Spiderman 2 as your favorite superhero movie? I don’t know about that, especially with the release of Iron Man but to each his own I guess, great post though.

  • Great work on your list. I would include Bruce Willis jumping off the building holding the fire house in original Die Hard then crashing through the window.
    I might be in the minority but I also love the sequence in Poseidon were Josh Licas jumps into the flaming water and pops up almost a different character. It’s very well directed and scored. Its become one of my all time favorite scenes.

  • Connor G

    great list, I had forgotten about a few of those but now that you bring them up, its hard to argue with any that made your list.

  • Milander

    Nice list but I’d have included:

    The final fight from Drunken master (jackie chan)

    fifth element, 7 on the left, 5 on the right (bang bang bang) 3 on the left 2 on the right – nice balance of action and comedy.

    Star wars – lukes fight against DVader at the end of Empire strike back

    the car chase sequence with the nitro in Mad Max!! how that was missed I don’t know!!

    Anyway, lists like these are always subjective, you’ve your opinion and I have mine. Keep it up m8.

  • @Milander: My list = action movies post-2000.

  • Great list.

  • dbwheeler

    My heart goes out to all of you who watch this sordid, sick and totally unaesthetic ‘stuff’. (stuff & nonsense in another age) In beauty there is truth…where do you think this so-called ‘reallity’ comes from? What or who do you think inspires it? Is this who you want to be? Is this WHERE you want to be?

  • @dbwheeler: You just blew my mind.

  • agh! Why does not dbwheeler not have a link to his website where I can go read more!

  • Ben Rees

    Great reviews dude, totally agree on the Children of Men review, the film was breath taking.

    (dbwheeler, in film or documentary there is no such thing as “truth”, there are just versions of reality that the editors choose to make.)

    Thanks for the post Jay C, keep up the good work.

  • Reed Farrington

    Jay hasn’t seen Shoot ‘Em Up, and everyone I’ve talked to hasn’t appreciated it, but I love the action in this film, in part because I love the character that Clive Owen plays. Having Peter Pau as the DP helps as well. (He was the DP on Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon.)

    Film critics loved the action in Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon and Hero, but these films seem under-appreciated on FilmJunk.

    If anyone has the same taste as I do and loved all three of the movies I just mentioned, then I highly recommend you seek out Chocolate. (I’ve mentioned this in the comments for the Chocolate trailer, but I’ll mention it again here because we are talking about action.) It starts slowly, but I even like this non-action stuff, because it’s photographed nicely.

    I’ve seen 8 of the films Jay mentioned, and even though I’ve been known to disagree with Jay just because he’s Jay, I have to say that his choices are technically proficient action sequences, but none of the 8 made me think, “Wow!”

  • Phrank

    Great list! I haven’t seen all of these, but whatever I have I definitely agree.

    I’d say one of the top ten, though, has to be the parkour scene in 2007’s Casino Royale, for quite a few reasons. First off, it’s just an incredibly tense and exciting sequence, and very little of it (what takes place on the crane, if I understand correctly) was done thru CG/green screen. But it’s also a very good example of using action to inform the audience. This was Daniel Craig’s first appearance as James Bond, and a lot of people were unsure, to say the least. This was the first extended scene in the movie, and used the running and fighting styles of the two characters (the bombmaker chased by Bond, and, well, Bond), to demonstrate how this new Bond deviates from what we’ve expected to be the norm. You may be at times uncomfortable, like when the bombmaker vaults so gracefully through a very small, high window, feet first, and then Bond just…CRASHES THROUGH THE WALL. This isn’t what James Bond does, you may say! But again…a new Bond, just like five minutes ago given 00- status. He’s young and reckless, and this entire sequence illustrates the changes in expectations we ought to have.

  • Could I please point out; a friend of mine, Nick Milner, was in charge of the prop’s for Children of Men and I can assure you most of what you see in that scene is real in a sense that the whole ‘immigrant camp’ thing really was there and built; there was practically no CGI.

    I got to visit it whilst they were filming and saw a lot of the filming; I even got a helitour of the ‘immigrant camp’.

    Good post though.

  • “1. Children of Men – The Long Take

    Children of Men

    Here is the perfect example of how to use CG in an action scene; invisibly.”

    For an even better and more visceral experience with this exact technique, check out Roman Polanskis The Pianist. I’m sure Alfonso Cuarón did.

    I think the United 93 ending is a gutwrenching punch in the gonads to watch, but anything in the Bourne films he did leaves me numb. I just don’t feel like there’s any truth to it at all, I could win a knifefight if it was broken into .5 second intervals.

    The Lord of the Rings thing I don’t get at all. I thought the action in all the films was pretty terrible, and the exact scene you describe is the moment I remember the first one losing me because I became bored.

    Hulk had good action scenes. Somehow they felt serene, and used their cartoon-esque visuals as a strength to create something kinetic and borderline playful, much like the Spider-Man 2 scene described above I think.

    I think one of the most visceral action scenes I can remember in recent history is the wallet-scene in Sideways. I don’t think there was any CGI in there at all!

  • MrZenCool

    For myself, I loved Wanted, especially the scene near the end. After watching that and being quite literally on the edge of my seat and holding my breath, I got to thinking about my own favorite fight/action scenes. (WARNING: FANBOYISM AHEAD)

    I would have to say that my all time favorite action scene of all time ever would be the final scenes of Equilibrium. First, the hallway massacre was done absolutely beautifully, especially the bit with the thrown clips. The fact it was done almost entirely without wires or CG (the only CG was the cross shaped muzzle flashes) just makes it all the more impressive. Then, at the very end, when Preston and Father are in that close quarter fight with the pistols, each trying to get the edge. . .it was a knife fight, pure and simple, made inventive and visceral with the addition of handguns.

    As for Wanted, I couldn’t tell you off hand what made it so awesome for me. I’ll definitely be buying it once it hits DVD, but until then I’ll have to speculate. In a lot of ways, it’s similar to the hallway scene from Equilibrium, where one, obviously superior man goes goes balls out and ****s up everything he possibly can. Sure, he gets hit a couple times, but just the incredible one-sidedness of it appeals to me. Whadda badass.

    One more thing before I go, I really liked Bourne Identity and the fight scenes in there, especially the bit with the pen. That said, I absolutely HATED Bourne Supremacy and only marginally liked Ultimatum. Why? Shaky cam. I understand why it’s done, to enhance the tension and the feeling of movement, but at the same time I’d like to see what is going on. When you shake the damn camera like an epileptic on speed, I can’t tell who is doing what to who.

    Anyway, my two cents

  • Goon

    “it’s similar to the hallway scene from Equilibrium”

    Equilibrium is probably the only action movie I can name that is even more boring than Wanted. Equilibrium is what happens when a 12 year old writes a sci fi movie and adults take it seriously.

  • Matt

    I don’t care when it was made. The landing scene from Saving Private Ryan should be #1.

  • The article that changed it all

  • Reed Farrington

    After careful consideration, I think I was too harsh on Jay’s choices. I think the naked knife fight in Eastern Promises would have been a “wow” moment for me if I hadn’t been expecting it.

    After reading some comments here, I went back and rewatched the staircase scene from The Protector (Tom yum goong). Watching the DVD special feature with the director describing the 5 takes that it took was awesome. For those that haven’t seen this, the reason the staircase scene is special is that it was done in one 4 minute take. So if someone got injured, it was, “Sorry, lad, wait until the scene is over.” I was awed by the fact that at one point, Tony Jaa picks up a guy and has to make sure he throws the guy onto a kiosk several flights down. He never misses in all 5 takes!

    Also, Phrank reminded me how much I enjoyed the action in Casino Royale as well. Definitely the best Bond, although other Bonds have had spectacular action sequences as well. The Quantum of Solace trailer is awesome IMO. And I’m beginning to get used to its title as well.

  • Pingback: YIKES. Back Online. - The Documentary Blog()

  • I haven’t watched Oldboy and Eastern Promises yet, will definitely do :)

    The only scenes I remember well are Spiderman2, Kill Bill and Deathproof.

    The scenes all over Children of Men are greatly done.

    What bout 300? and Indiana Jones 4?

  • Yeah, that’s a hell of a list. You nailed it. Especially the #1 – Children of men, that scene is f***in awesome. I also strongly agree with the Oldboy scene placement.

    Dugg it ;)
    Greets from Germany,
    Rob