Treknobabble #12: What Has Gone Before At The Movies, Part 3

treknobabble12_generations.jpg

Treknobabble is a continuing series of columns written by uber-Trekkie Reed Farrington in anticipation of the upcoming J.J. Abrams Star Trek movie.

With The Next Generation leaving the television airwaves on a high-note and movie reviewers constantly making geriatric references to the Original Series crew, it was time for the new crew to take over the movies. To Rick Berman’s credit, Berman thought the next movie should involve some sort of handing of a baton from the old crew over to the new crew. Besides, having a movie with both Captain Picard and Captain Kirk seemed like sure box-office success.

Star Trek: Generations

Star Trek: Generations was supposed to have the triumvirate of Kirk, Spock and McCoy in it, but we ended up with Kirk, Scotty, and Chekov. A Kirk sky-diving sequence from orbit was cut from the beginning of the film. But it was too late for the toy presses to stop production of a Kirk in a space sky-diving outfit.

Both Kirk and Picard were so old that they had difficulty together beating up one villain played by Alex from A Clockwork Orange. Kirk and Picard do become dobby droogs, but Kirk snuffs it twice. First, he gets razrezed into space and then later, he lands on his gulliver. Originally, Kirk got oobivated by Alex from a laser pooshka blast to the back. But test screenings had the audiences crarking and creeching at the screen. So the producers had to spend some more cutter and reshoot the ending. If only Kirk had had a shlem.

Many people were confused with how one could get into the Nexus that allowed you to “live” in any experience that you imagined. Soran was blowing up worlds in order to change the gravitational effects on the Nexus so that the Nexus would pass over a planet that Soran could be on. But why couldn’t Soran just fly into the Nexus with a spacecraft? After all, Kirk had gotten in the Nexus when it had struck a starship section that Kirk had been in.

Guinan, the space hostess on The Next Generation, is somehow linked with the Nexus. Wait, wasn’t Guinan able to get Picard into the Nexus in order to bring Kirk back. So why didn’t they get Guinan to bring Soran into the Nexus?

Anyway, because of the nebulous workings of the Nexus, I’m sure some explanation could be worked out to bring Kirk back again.

Many people thought this movie was boring and that only when Shatner appeared did the movie liven up. It was strange to hear people appreciating Shatner after all the years that people were lambasting him for his over-acting.

The Enterprise-D was destroyed. People unkindly noted that Counselor Troi was driving at the time.

I do like the message of the film of making a difference in the world of reality. Come to think of it, the movie seems to be saying that playing video games in an imagined world where nothing really matters is meaningless.

Star Trek: First Contact

Star Trek: First Contact had the Borg. Many people enjoyed this film. Number One (Riker) directed this film. This film did so well that they got him to direct the next movie as well.

treknobabble12_firstcontact.jpg

There’s time travel, and we get to see humanity’s first meeting with the Vulcans.

Marina Sirtis as Troi got some praise for her drunken scenes.

The scene where the Borg queen’s head and spinal column connects to the rest of her body was a highlight.

Alice Krige as the Borg queen was very sexy.

People seemed to enjoy Picard’s speech about having had enough of the Borg before accidentally destroying the Enterprise models in the display case.

Star Trek: Insurrection

Star Trek: Insurrection was written by Michael Piller, the man that many considered made The Next Generation so popular. Ironically, most people either hated this film or never bothered seeing it. There’s a cute CGI chipmunky animal that was added to sell merchandise, but I think I’m the only person with the Beanie Baby version of this thing.

treknobabble12_insurrection.jpg

This movie was about a planet where something in the atmosphere kept everyone young, and the plan by the Federation to relocate the inhabitants. Picard and crew side with the inhabitants.

Picard’s kiss with a woman is edited out.

Star Trek: Nemesis

Star Trek: Nemesis put the nail in the coffin. This movie had everything going for it. A famed editor/director who had directed some decent action movies. A hot writer who had Spielberg and Scorsese asking him for his services. Data dies in this one. Sort of. Frankly, I don’t understand why Data had to sacrifice himself.

treknobabble12_nemesis.jpg

A younger clone of Picard is the nemesis with plans to take over Earth.

We get to meet another of Data’s “brothers.” This brother is more retarded than a Pakled.

Oh, this movie has Romulans in it.

So that wraps up all the Star Trek movies. I know I’ve given short shrift to the Next Generation movies.

All the Star Trek movies are so inexpensive right now on DVD that they’re practically disposable. So if I’ve piqued your interest at all, go out and sample one or two of them. And tell me what you think.

New extras are currently being filmed for the re-release of these movies on Blu-Ray. David Gerrold, “The Trouble with Tribbles” writer, was recently interviewed to comment on the crew assembly scene in The Motion Picture for its Blu-Ray release. Many non-actors were given a chance to be in a Star Trek movie through this scene where Kirk announces the mission to the crew.

Normally, to announce a mission in the television series, Kirk would just sit in his comfy bridge chair and page the entire ship using a button embedded in his chair. I don’t know why he just didn’t tell Uhura to open up a hailing frequency for paging the ship. Nowadays, the only control buttons I ever see on chairs are on massage loungers. Maybe this was a feature we never got to see on Star Trek’s bridge chairs.

Back to the crew assembly scene, I always wondered how Kirk would have responded to late stragglers to this meeting on the crew deck. In Star Trek’s future, everyone is always on time.

If you do try watching any of these Star Trek movies as your first exposure to Star Trek, I hope you’re not disappointed. In any case, I’m guessing that J.J. Abrams’ Star Trek will be completely different. Abrams has the money to do anything he wants with the latest visual effects. The actors are young enough to do stunts that the series’ actors were too old to do. And… darn it. I haven’t got a big finish.



  • Not a big fan of any of the TNG movies (the old crew went out on a high note with The Undiscovered Country), it was strange since the villains in 3/4 of TNG movies are played by really good (even iconic) actors, in particular F. Murray Abraham and Malcolm MacDowell, and I have a real soft spot fo Alice Krige, even hamming it up in the Silent Hill movie.

    I think TNG writers got really lazy with the Borg and Time Travel devices that were overly played out in The Original Series…

  • B-4 is indeed more retarded than the Pakled. Were they realy retarded though? Smarter than a starfleet Lt. Cmdr.!

    This part 12 is a depressing read. I think you’re tough on the films, but it could just be me who’s too kind toward them. I’m sure you feel the same way with people making posts like this about The Final Frontier.

    Insurrection has a good main theme and nice visual effects. Those two elements can make nearly anything watchable (see also: The Time Machine remake (apropos uber-asshole John Logan), Mortal Kombat, Star Wars I-VI).

  • Reed Farrington

    That’s a strange photo Sean found for Generations. Looks like a mini-Picard is doing a jig on Soran’s arm.

    Yeah, I felt like a turd-head for dismissing the Next Gen films with a few off-hand comments.

    Henrik, you’re going to be suicidal after reading my Rise and Fall of The Next Generation Treknobabble article.

  • “That’s a strange photo Sean found for Generations. Looks like a mini-Picard is doing a jig on Soran’s arm.” = LOL.

    Loved First Contact. Hated Insurrection (though the chick Picard doesn’t kiss is hot). I fascinated with the Borg and even more fascinated with developing a story that is closer to our own time (sort of why I didn’t hate T3, because I like how everthing is explained and it takes place a very few short years from now).

  • But Andrew, if you like the borg you should despise First Contact. They’re never scary again.

  • I read your review on Star Trek Generations, having just watched it last night I have the story fresh in mind, your review and speculation is full of obvious narrative holes.

    Let me explain a few:
    for one, they explained why you couldnt fly into the Nexus with a ship, it would buckle under the stress as we saw in the first 10 minutes. Although the lifesigns on the ships were phasing in and out of the current space/time continuum, when the ships exploded a fair few wouldn’t of survived. Kirk was lucky that he phased into the Nexus before the vacuum of space took him.

    Guinan was not responsible at all for Picard getting into the Nexus, he was on the planet with Zoren when the Nexus took them… the Guinan Picard encountered was an echo of the woman that was ripped away, something like a spirit, so there was no way she could return with Picard, cos in reality she already was, on board the Enterprise-D.

    I have no problem with critiquing films, whether its negative or positive in its review, but it should be accurate otherwise its just embarrassing.

  • @Chris: Thx for trying to clear up my speculations. (BTW, I’m never embarrassed about being wrong, but I’d be embarrassed if I told someone they were wrong when they weren’t. :-))

    I don’t remember there being anything said about phasing in and out of the space/time continuum, but I’ll take your word for it. I’ve got a new speculation then. Why didn’t Soran exit a spaceship with a life-support suit on and let the Nexus pass over him? (Actually, how did he know that he had a better chance entering the Nexus from a planet than a spaceship?)

    Regarding Picard, Soran, echo Guinan, and Kirk, I’m trying to remember what my point was. You’re correct in saying that Picard and Soran got put into the Nexus when Soran was able to get it to pass over them. I don’t remember how Picard was able to meet up with the echo Guinan in the Nexus. Was it the echo Guinan who arranged that? Was it the echo Guinan who got Picard to meet up with Kirk? I guess I’m confused as to the point of going back to the planet with Kirk just before Soran launched the missile. Would they have been able to go back earlier to before Soran started destroying planets? Couldn’t Picard and Kirk have gotten more people to come out of the Nexus to help with stopping Soran? I suppose if you don’t question the Nexus (or the Red Matter in the latest Star Trek movie), then you’ll be satisfied with what happens in the movie.